Most locals don’t think about the housing market beyond whether they can make their next Florida mortgage loan payment — or get approved for that first loan in the first place. Sure, some look into the future and see a weakening housing market… but we really don’t care. Or worry.
We have been told many, many times that normalization of the housing market will return and that stagnant sales and home prices pose no real problems for the rest of the economy. But, Britain’s Daily Reckoning cautions, we may be overlooking alarming signs with this attitude.
“Things do seem to be getting worse very quickly. Free-fall is a strong word, but I think it’s the right one to use here,” Paul Ashworth, Chief Economist at Capital Economics, said.
But most Americans fear not. They have been told that soft housing prices pose no problems for the overall economy, and have no reason to doubt that this is the case, no reason to squint and try to see further down the line. They dread neither slump nor boom, neither war nor peace. Everything will be managed by the authorities, they believe.
But there is no such thing as an expected emergency. You typically don’t think you’re going to lose money in an investment. No one plans on losing his life savings. It comes as a surprise, along with sudden death, financial turmoil, and far worse crises. Where will the surprise come from this time, and how will it impact the world economically?
We wonder this, because things that are expected present few opportunities and few catastrophes. When an older person dies, people gather at his/her burial site with a sense of relief. Finally, the heartbreak is over. Their life insurance is straightened out. The estate is distributed. The book is closed and put down. Time to move on.
But when a younger person dies, it is as if the printer of said book made a mistake. The story is unfinished. We turn the page and find nothing there.
The young man typically dies suddenly, leaving his widow and children grieving in the house. Neighbors discuss behind closed doors, taking what was once his, what might have been (local banks, meanwhile, wonder if the Florida mortgage they lent out will ever be repaid).
If there are going to be difficult years in America, however, Americans are not worrying. They recall the last “recession” in 2001, almost fondly. Even before they had forgone a single donut or eschewed one new pair of pants, the recession was over. And on its heels came the biggest boom in housing prices the world had ever seen.
Recession? The last one was no trouble in the end, just a minor inconvenience, if that. Why should they worry about another quote-unquote housing bubble this time around?
The expected slump poses no danger to them. But what if the slump is not as expected? What if the softening of home prices is not so benign? What if the roof really does cave in? Now that would come as a shock.
The Guardian took up the idea this week:
“The downturn in the U.S. housing market will force businesses to slash 73,000 jobs a month in the new year and could be more damaging to the world economy than the dot com crash, economists have warned. Fears are mounting that the ‘orderly’ housing slowdown predicted by the Federal Reserve will become a full-blown crash.”
The paper quotes Paul Ashworth:
“House prices have been appreciating at unprecedented double-digit rates in recent years, giving homeowners massive windfalls and supporting a wave of investment in new construction. However, the number of unsold new homes is now at a 10-year high.”
Ashworth believes that 30 percent of all the jobs created since the end of the last recession in 2001 — 1.4 million — have been in sectors related to the housing market boom, from mortgage lenders to construction workers and builders, to real estate agents to people working at home improvement stores. As the boom runs out of steam, up to 73,000 jobs a month will be lost, he estimates.
For a wealth-dependent U.S. economy, the bursting of another major asset bubble is likely to be a very big deal. With U.S. trade and other fiscal imbalances larger than five years ago, the fallout for the rest of the world could be more devastating than the aftermath of the dot com boom if home prices do indeed plummet.
What is unanticipated, but very possible, is a hard landing. Will it come? We don’t know. But at least we haven’t failed to anticipate it. Nor should you.