Sales of previously owned homes in the Sarasota-Bradenton market dropped 39 percent during November, mirroring the national trend of a cooling real estate market where the number of existing homes available for sale is at a 19-year high.
Sarasota-Bradenton’s drop from 1,010 homes sold during November 2004, to 621 last month, depicted Florida’s highest in percentage terms. It also was the slowest performance for the market since September 2003.
Another sector of the state that suffered was The Charlotte County-North Port market, which saw 15 percent fewer sales (from 289 to 245), according to the Florida Association of Realtors.
“Last year at Christmas I wrote 10 contracts — year before, wrote seven. This year, I wrote one. That’s a buyer’s market,” said Gary Macklin, owner of Help-U-Sell Macklin Realty in Port Charlotte and Punta Gorda.
Median home prices in these areas
The Sarasota-Bradenton market’s median price was $343,600, up 34 percent from last year and on par with recent months. Meanhwhile, The Charlotte County-North Port market posted a median sales price of $236,900, a 41 percent increase and among the highest on a percentage basis in Florida.
Statewide, home sales rose 1 percent and the median sales price rose 31 percent to $259,500. This is proof that the Florida home loan market is still going strong.
Nationally, the number of existing homes available for sale rose 1.2 percent in November to a pace of 2.90 million units, the highest level since April 1986. At the same time that sales have slowed, the number of listings available in the Sarasota-Bradenton market tripled, and they continue to pile up. There’s no doubt that this is a buyer’s market in Florida.
Relax. It’s just one month of Florida home loan news.
Real estate agents were quick to point out the danger in reading too much into one month’s numbers, particularly during a traditionally slow time for sales.
“You’ve got to look at year-to-date numbers,” said Michael Saunders, president of the Sarasota realty company that bears her name. “If I just looked at November, I’d slit my wrists.”
Let’s hope that no Florida real estate agent takes it that far. Still, the November figures compared
with a month last year when the real estate market was still reeling somewhat from the impact of Hurricane Charley in the region.
“This market is going to fall a little bit,” Macklin said. “Sellers are going to say, ‘I can’t wait anymore, I will take $20,000 less.’ That is going to change the comps for the next sales. So the market has to settle. There are more people signing up every day to sell.”
The slow rise of mortgage rates
Moderately rising mortgage rates are allowing the housing market so far to cool slowly, easing fears about a crash, economists say.
The average interest rate on 30-year mortgages in November was 6.33 percent, up from 6.07 percent in October. This week, however, rates on 30-year mortgages dipped to 6.22 percent, Freddie Mac reported Thursday.
Real estate agents said the Sarasota-Bradenton market will probably post moderately lower sales this year than last.
John Lafabregue, a Sarasota Re/Max agent who tracks the statistics, estimated that about 6,500 existing single-family homes will be sold in Sarasota this year, compared with 6,923 last year. That would be a 6 percent decline.
He claims that Southwest Florida is still a “seller’s market,” describing it as “hot.”
A different way of tracking Florida home sales?
Other real estate agents also said they would prefer a different statistic to illustrate the state of the real estate market, but acknowledge that the latter part of 2005 has been slower.
“The fourth quarter, for the market, was not great,” said Chad Roffers of SKY Sotheby’s International Realty in Sarasota.
Roffers notes that with a median sales price of $343,600, Sarasota-Bradenton “has caught up with the other luxury markets and is now the fourth-highest median sales price market in the state,” after Naples, Fort Lauderdale and Miami.
Part of the slowdown in sales is that many speculative buyers have backed away.
“Investors — who represented about one-third of the market — are stepping to the sidelines,” Roffers said, adding that there is a “disconnect between buyer expectation and seller expectation.”
Sellers need to target end-user buyers because the investors have pulled in their horns, Roffers said.
Among other larger metropolitan areas, Miami posted the second-biggest decrease in sales with a 25 percent drop. Fort Lauderdale was third at 21 percent. Part of the problem - a good one to have - is that the Florida home loan market in Miami was so hot for so long, there was bound to be a downfall eventually.
Closer to home, Naples posted a 5 percent increase, while its median sales price rose 36 percent to the state’s highest at $479,800. In the Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater market, sales rose 16 percent and the median sales price rose 33 percent to $222,900.
None of the state’s 20 largest markets saw a decline in prices: increases ranged from 12 percent in Tallahassee to 49 percent in Fort Myers-Cape Coral.
Peter Crowley, president of Sarasota’s Re/Max Properties, blames “constant media attention” for creating an idea with sellers “of sitting on the sidelines.”
“We’re not panicking. Nothing drastic has happened,” he said. The November figures might be skewed because they are “being compared to the hottest market in our history.”
There is a natural cooling-off occurring in the market, which is “not an unhealthy thing,” Crowley said.
Crowley doesn’t expect prices to plummet, but he also does not expect homeowners to continue to see 30-percent-plus appreciation.
This follows the line of reasoning mentioned above. While the numbers for Florida home loans appear to be dwindling, one needs to compare these with the record-breaking figures from earlier this year. That pace was impossible to maintain, but it doesn’t mean the 2006 real estate market won’t be strong.